A Systems View Across Time and Space
From: Hack your organizational innovation: literature review and integrative model for running hackathons
Articles | The current article (2022) | Komssi et al. (2014) | Pe-Than et al. (2018) | Olesen and Halskov (2020) | Valença et al. (2020) | Jaakola et al. (2021) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Criteria | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â | Â |
Focus | State-of-the-art review on planning and executing hackathons in a step-by-step fashion | Non-systematic review of hackathons in the technology and software domains | Non-systematic review on how to design hackathons in light of specific goals | Review of the hackathons’ usage in research | A systematic review focusing on corporate hackathons in the IT industry | Case study on how to execute short-term events in the tech and software domain in a step-by-step fashion |
Methodology | A systematic review of the literature | Non-systematic review of the literature and case studies | Non-systematic review of the literature and case studies | A systematic review of the literature | A systematic review of the literature | Case study |
Does it offer a process model? | Â | x | Â | x | Â | Â |
Stages of the process model | Divided into pre-, during-, and post-event guidelines, emphasizing project continuity | N/A | Divided into design choices and strategies based on goals | N/A | Divided into pre-, during-, and post-event guidelines | Divided into pre-, during-, and post-event guidelines |
Main Contribution | Offers an in-depth, research- and practitioner-oriented, step-by-step model on how to best execute hackathons (regardless of domain or subject) and secure their success and continuation based on empirical literature | Details how hackathons are commonly used in the technology domains and describes such hackathons, their challenges, and outcomes | Describes hackathon participants’ and stakeholders’ organizational and personal goals and provides design guidelines on how to best achieve them | Maps how hackathons are used as both tools for research and subjects of research based on empirical literature | Focuses on corporate hackathons and offers a step-by-step model on how to execute them and secure their success based on empirical literature | Provides and tests a general step-by-step model on best executing short-term events (of which hackathons are one type) |